Welcome to TheShiznit.co.uk, your home for movie news, movie reviews and more!
Sign In or Register

Review: Black Swan

Black Swan
Director    Darren Aronofsky
Starring    Natalie Portman, Mila Kunis, Vincent Cassell, Barbara Hershey, Winona Ryder, Benjamin Millipied
Release    17 DEC (US) 21 JAN (UK)    Certificate 15


How to describe Black Swan? Ballet-based lesbionic headfuck just about does it - there certainly aren't too many pigeon holes you can bash this particular peg into. Though it touches on a number of genres and encapsulates several themes, Black Swan is best viewed as a horror movie - a slow creep into insanity that's touching and terrifying in equal measure.

Black Swan is The Natalie Portman Show: a shop window for one of the most talented actresses in Hollywood. She plays Nina Sayers, a porcelain ballerina whose fragility is down in no small part to her overbearing mother, Erica (Barbara Hershey). To play the lead in her company's production of Swan Lake, Nina must embrace her Black Swan - the sinister yin to her white and fluffy yang. Pummelled under the barbaric tutelage of her director Tomas (Vincent Cassell) and led astray by competitor Lily (Mila Kunis), Nina begins a inexorable descent into madness.

Obvious alert: Natalie Portman is phenomenal - it's a virtuoso performance of hard graft. The parallels between Darren Aronofsky's narrative and that of Swan Lake are hardly subtle - in fact, they're frequently mentioned - but it's a role that puts her through the wringer; one that requires lightness of touch and wells of inner turmoil to draw from. 2011 may be the year you get sick of Natalie Portman (she may have as many as seven films released before the summer) but Black Swan will be the one you remember. Or maybe Thor. Probably Black Swan. But maybe No Strings Attached. No, definitely Black Swan.

What do you mean, 'over-exposed'?

Aronofsky serves his leading lady well, propelling her through a nightmarish journey and surrounding her with all manner of ghouls, wretches and damned souls. Kunis, representing Nina's dark side, doesn't have as demanding a role as Portman, but she's solid support and plays her part well - she's Nina's Tyler Durden and careens through the movie with the same carefree cackle. Vincent Cassell brings the same swinging dick Euro-swagger he always does, sleazing up the joint and shagging everything that moves. Tsk, the French.

There's a general feeling of pervasive unease that lies beneath Black Swan's ruffled feathers that has you on edge even in the slower scenes. Nina has a literal dark side - a smouldering alter-ego of whom you only catch frightening, stolen glimpses. Every set is covered in mirrors, giving a true sense that there is nowhere for Nina to hide. (I could be wrong, but it looked to me like all the mirror reflections were slightly off, like they'd been shot separately.) Clint Mansell's score gnaws away at the nervous system.

It's called symbolism, jerkbag. Look it up.

Black Swan is a movie that's constantly on a knife-edge and that's down to Aronofsky's masterful composition, impeccable framing and stunning use of shadow and light. The scares never feel cheap and the shocks last longer than most - the final half hour is a queasy cocktail of psychological torture and Cronenberg-esque body horror. There are hints of self-harming, schizophrenia, homicidal tendencies and even incest. In short, it's fucking creepy - some of the more disturbing images will linger for days.

It's a wonder I'm surprised. Aronofsky has shown time and time again that he can deliver an unforgettable experience, no matter how bizarre the source material sounds and whatever the genre. Black Swan could be his best movie yet; a fascinating portrait of obsession and the price of pursuing perfection. And yes, you're now officially allowed to be excited about Wolverine 2. It'll probably scare the shit out of you.

Add Your Comments

You are not signed in! Enter your details below, or click here to register.
Email Address:

Latest Comment

Click here to read all 14 user comments.
Posted by Nick at 05:06 on 20/05/11
"And seeing the mum at the finale applauding & smiling made me think "ok so 5mins before she was trying to prevent her from leaving but now is proud mum?".
Which suggested to me the entire mum issue was yet another result of Nina being loopy."

Having just watched it again, it's pretty obvious to me at least that the mum is a borderline personality wreck. That would actually fit perfectly into this film because people with BPD see things in extreme black and white, good and bad. Her reaction to the cake rejection when she goes to throw the whole thing in the bin, the control and obsession over her daughter, perfectionism and keeping away other people is all classic BPD behaviour. In all likelihood, Nina smashing her hand in a door and then walking out would cause the mother to reject her and it's extremely unlikely she would then go to the show. I imagine that would be a fantasy, which brings up the question, how in the blue hell are you supposed to be able to distinguish between fantasy and reality?

I will say I found the bluray a little disappointing. The convertion isn't the highest quality and it isn't helped by large parts of the film being so dark. The club scene in particular I found near impossible to track.
Out this week
+Dunkirk (12A)
Read our review | Related articles
+Monster Island (PG)
Don't act like you weren't thinking this
+Scribe (15)