Welcome to TheShiznit.co.uk, your home for movie news, movie reviews and more!
Sign In or Register

Review: Carnage

Carnage
Director    Roman Polanski
Starring    Kate Winslet, Christoph Waltz, Jodie Foster, John C Reilly
Release    3 FEB (UK)    Certificate 15

Rating:


If you type 'Carnage' into IMDB, you'll find it is the alternative title to The Nail Gun Massacre, A Bay Of Blood and even Prime Cut, an early Gene Hackman film about a cattle rancher who "grinds his enemies into sausage". It's the kind of title you'd expect to see propped up on the bargain shelf at Asda with a cover showing Stone Cold Steve Austin walking away from an exploding jeep. And yet here I am reviewing Roman Polanski's new low-key character-based comedy. It's almost a shame.

Based on a play - Le Dieu du carnage by Yasmina Reza - Carnage is not only an obvious adaptation throughout, what with its one camera, one-location set-up, it is probably the most play-iest film I have ever seen. You get the impression that if Winslet & co spared more time from their busy schedules, they could have rehearsed for weeks and filmed this all in one take.

While this won't seem very enticing to cinemagoers who prefer seeing more pixels for their pound, Carnage is actually very accessible, really enjoyable and, thanks mostly to a brilliant cast with an undeniable talent for comedy, really rather funny.


A man wearing no trousers is ALWAYS funny


The premise is embarrassingly simple: two sets of parents meet up to discuss a fight that broke out between their two children at school. As their conversation develops, forced pleasantries give way to stubborn passive aggressiveness and, come the film's end, descend into full-on, out of control, reckless behaviour.

Kate Winslet and Christoph Waltz play the busy work-hards who are guests at try-hards Jodie Foster and John C Reilly's house. Where Winslet is the initial peacemaker of the group, Foster is the antagonised shrew determined to see full justice done on behalf of her son. Meanwhile, Waltz and Reilly get to bond over a shared exasperation at their wives' irrationality before finding tension between themselves, exacerbated by the fact that Waltz keeps taking important phone calls.


Ok, I'll say it - those tulips are ridiculous


Set entirely in a Brooklyn apartment (though obviously not filmed there *wags finger at Polanski*), you'd think that the film would be a visual dullard, but Polanski switches angles and makes optimum use of the space he has to keep the film from feeling too claustrophobic.

In fact, despite the obvious restrictions of the film, this could be Polanski's most accessible work for years: a lighthearted character farce filled with entertaining performances and probably some biting social commentary that went over my head.

Now excuse me while I search Amazon for Stone Cold Steve Austin films.


Add Your Comments

You are not signed in! Enter your details below, or click here to register.
Email Address:
Password:

Latest Comment

Click here to read all 2 user comments.
Nick
Posted by Nick at 15:36 on 14/01/13
I wanted to like it but struggled because every character is such a detestable jackass. It's not clever, funny or sharp enough to be enjoyable.
Out this week
+The Expendables 3 (12A)
Our review | All articles
+The Congress (15)
Our review
+The Rover (15)
+The Unbeatables (U)
+Hector And The Search For Happiness (15)
+Blood Ties (15)